Kentucky Derby 2015: American Pharoah Wins a Close Race

LOUISVILLE, Ky. — It was no secret that Bob Baffert had brought a couple of big horses to America’s biggest race, the Kentucky Derby: Dortmund had never been beaten, and his stablemate, American Pharoah, was being compared to the great Seattle Slew. In fact, some closed their eyes and transported themselves back to 1948, when the legendary trainer Ben Jones brought a couple of iconic colts named Citation and Coaltown to Churchill Downs.

What most wanted to know, however, was which of Baffert’s two colts was better. For weeks, Baffert, the white-haired trainer, had to do something that did not come naturally: He had to dodge the question. He had to keep his own counsel.

It was wise, of course — the owner of Dortmund, Kaleem Shah, and the owner of American Pharoah, Ahmed Zayat, each provided Baffert with an ample number of quality horses. Why alienate one or the other? It was also necessary: Baffert was not sure.

Continue reading the main story
RELATED COVERAGE

Philip S. Birsh, president and chief executive of the theater publication Playbill, in his Manhattan office.Going From Broadway to Racing’s Biggest StageMAY 2, 2015
Fans in front of the new owners boxes at Churchill Downs on Friday. The racetrack added 20 boxes behind the winner’s circle after an owner complained about his experience last year.Notebook: Churchill Downs Bolsters Its Hospitality After a High-Profile Criticism MAY 2, 2015
American Pharoah was last year’s 2-year-old champion and has won four of his five races.On Horse Racing: At Long Last, a Kentucky Derby Only About the HorsesMAY 1, 2015
The Kentucky Derby contender Carpe Diem was bathed after his workout at Keeneland in Lexington, Ky., recently.Kentucky Derby 2015: Predictions and AnalysisAPRIL 30, 2015
Trainer Seeks the Finish He Started 10 Years AgoAPRIL 25, 2015
He had kept the colts apart the past five months, with Dortmund dominating in California in three impressive victories against what was considered the stiffest competition in the land. American Pharoah, who was injured late in his 2-year-old campaign, was dispatched to Arkansas in March and April — on the late side — for two tuneups that looked like workouts, as he won the Rebel Stakes by six and a quarter lengths and the Arkansas Derby by eight.